How India’s Two Flagship Indices Are Built and Compared

Close-up of a stock market chart with candlestick patterns and moving averages

Millions of Indians follow market movements every day through two familiar numbers, yet relatively few know how those numbers are actually constructed. Headlines announce that the Nifty 50 has fallen or risen by a certain percentage, and readers of a Sensex Today bulletin see a similar figure from the Bombay Stock Exchange. Although the two indices usually move in the same direction, they are built differently, track different baskets of companies, and can occasionally diverge. Understanding how they work makes it easier to interpret daily market reports and to choose appropriate index-linked investments.

Table of Contents

The Purpose of a Stock Index

A stock index is a statistical measure of the performance of a representative group of shares. Instead of tracking the performance of thousands of listed companies, investors can track a smaller number representing a particular segment of the market. Indices are also a useful benchmark against which to measure the performance of mutual funds, and underlie exchange-traded funds and index funds, which allow investors to buy the entire basket with one transaction.

An index is only as good as its design. A good index is large enough to reflect the market, liquid enough to be traded and rebalanced regularly to reflect current realities, rather than old ones.

Composition and Selection

The National Stock Exchange benchmark is made up of fifty of the largest and most liquid companies listed on the exchange, spanning around a dozen or more sectors. The Bombay Stock Exchange benchmark, which has a much longer history going back to 1986, comprises thirty well-established companies from leading industries. As a result of having fewer stocks, each has a bigger weight in the BSE index, which makes it a little more sensitive to the movements of a few heavyweights.

Both indices are reviewed periodically and typically twice a year; companies that no longer meet criteria related to market capitalisation, trading volume and free float may be removed and replaced by others that do. This rebalancing reflects the evolution of the economy and the rise of new industries.

The Free-Float Method

Both indices use a free-float market capitalisation approach, instead of counting all shares issued by a company, only those available for public trading are counted, excluding stakes held by promoters, governments and strategic investors. This reflects the true market value of shares that can influence price movements.

Weightage and Concentration

As a result of being weighted by free-float market value, larger companies have greater influence on the index. A one per cent move in a heavyweight bank or a large conglomerate will move the index far more than the same move in a smaller constituent. Financial services typically have the largest sectoral weight in both indices, followed by information technology, oil and gas and consumer goods.

This concentration is reflected in the fact that the fall in the banking sector on Monday had a disproportionately large effect on headline numbers, despite many other sectors also falling.

Key Differences Between the Two

Apart from the number of stocks, the two benchmarks also differ in base year and base value. The BSE index uses 1978-79 as its base with a value of 100, whereas the NSE index uses November 1995 as its base with a value of 1,000. The use of different base years is why the BSE index is quoted at a much higher absolute level, even though percentage movements tend to be similar.

The NSE benchmark, with its larger basket, offers slightly better diversification and is the underlying reference for the most actively traded derivatives contracts in the country. The BSE benchmark, being older, has more historical and symbolic significance, and day-to-day percentage moves are usually within a fraction of each other, but differences can arise when sector-specific news affects one constituent more.

Beyond the Headline Indices

India has a wide ecosystem of other indices that reflect different market segments. Midcap and smallcap indices reflect companies below the large-cap tier and often move more sharply. Sectoral indices focus on banking, technology, pharmaceuticals, realty and other industries, providing a way to assess the health of individual sectors. Thematic and strategy indices focus on things such as low volatility, dividend yield and momentum.

Investors can take advantage of low-cost index funds and exchange-traded funds that replicate these benchmarks. As such products simply follow the index, rather than trying to beat it, they tend to have lower expense ratios than actively managed funds, making them a popular choice for long-term wealth building.

Using Index Knowledge Wisely

Understanding index construction can help investors to avoid misinterpretations of stock performance. An index fall does not necessarily mean every stock has fallen, some constituents may have risen. Likewise a rise driven by a handful of heavyweights may be masking weakness underneath. Looking at market breadth, sectoral performance and midcap and smallcap trends provides a more rounded view.

For those investing through index products, it is a good reminder that returns will follow the index, including its periods of decline. Matching the investment horizon to the asset class is crucial, and staying invested through cycles is essential for wealth building. With a better understanding of how the benchmarks are constructed, everyday market news becomes much easier to read, and far less mysterious.

Key Points

  • The Nifty 50 includes fifty of the largest and most liquid companies, while the Sensex comprises thirty well-established companies.
  • Both indices employ a free-float market capitalisation approach, only counting shares available for public trading to better reflect true market values.
  • The BSE index has a longer history, using 1978-79 as its base year with a value of 100, compared to the NSE’s base year of November 1995 with a value of 1,000.
  • Financial services constitute the largest sectoral weight in both indices, influencing index movements significantly with shifts in heavyweight stocks.
  • There is a broad ecosystem of other indices in India, including midcap, smallcap, and sectoral indices, reflecting different market segments and investment strategies.
  • Understanding index construction helps investors accurately interpret stock performance, as an index’s movement may not reflect the performance of all underlying stocks.
Share:

Emmett River Scott: Emmett, a culture journalist, writes about arts and entertainment, pop culture trends, and celebrity news.